Deists believe that gods existence can be seen in nature, using the godgiven ability of reason and should not depend on faith. The existence of an orderly universe containing life points to a creator. A deistic god does not tell us how to live our lives and does not t. Huston smith, author of the worlds religions this is a. As i have read much atheist literature, i am very aware of their basic arguments, which boil down to the claim that evolutionism puts god out of a job, the existence of. Also included are eight chapters in which other significant philosophers. Explore topics arguing gods existence philosophical arguments for god experiential arguments for god arguments against god.
It is perfectly evident to my mind that there exists a necessary, eternal. God made the world this wayanimal suffering and all. The problem with these types of polls and threads is the definition of god is so well undefined that its impossible to get a full grasp. Dawkins is a gifted writer, and his position at a leading. Deism is the philosophical position that rejects revelation as a source of religious knowledge. Deists also do not believe in obedience to a church or a book. The very fact that pro has lumped all these attributes in with this conclusion demonstrates that the deistic god is a bad theory precisely because it tries to explain everything, by becoming a theory of literally anything. That means you can toss out divine revelation, intervention, miracles, anthropomorphization, holy books, religious dogma, a purp. He does not distance himself from that which he creates. But one thing should be noted which craig also notes, when he says personal he is not meaning it in the sense of personal theistic vs. Neither can be proven in a scientific way that god does not exist.
The former being i reject the claim that a god does exist. Blount and the rest who figured in lelands book would have accepted the term deist as. A deist is defined as one who believes in the existence of a god or supreme being but denies revealed religion, basing his belief on the light of nature and reason. Likewise, some deists believe in an afterlife while others do not, etc. Deists deny the trinity, the inspiration of the bible, the deity of christ, miracles, and any supernatural act of redemption or salvation. It appears that more and more cosmologists dont have much confidence in the notion of a deistic god, but few cosmologists claim such a god is impossible. The deists who presented purely rationalist proofs for the existence of god, usually variations on the argument from the design or order of the universe, were able to derive support from the vision of the lawful physical world that sir isaac newton had delineated. Whats the problem with a deistic god as opposed to a. Deism is the belief that our universe was created by a god but that theres little if any evidence that such a god intervenes in human or earthly matters. With all of its fallacies such as translation errors, update errors, etc etc etc and simply not just talk to people.
Although it is rooted in a caricature of the kalam cosmological arguments first premise whatever begins to exist has a cause, it is a positive argument for atheism, and it does attempt to deal with the god hypothesis in the only arena where gods existence. The deistic god cant be proven not to exist because he doesnt intervene and exists somewhere beyond our means of observing. A main reason for this oversight is that american deism had to function within the. A deist believes that god exists and created the world, but does not interfere with his creation. Unlike many books of this sort, kreefts introduction aids the reader into the debate and if one is new to the questions of philosophy, the background provided become even more important. A god is going to lower itself to actually use a book. What evidences are there that show deism is false and a deistic creator does not exist. Deism draws the inference that god exists from the existence of. While deists agree that the bible is not the inspired word of god, opinions about jesus differ. The god delusion is a 2006 book by english biologist richard dawkins, a professorial fellow at. I am glad that the question was asked in such a way to reflect only the deistic concept, and not any theistic concept. Deism, an unorthodox religious attitude that found expression among a group of english writers in the 17th and 18th centuries. It stops short of making any specific claims about god or promoting any particular holy book. In part ii of the book, i will use evidence, or more precisely, the lack of evidence where evidence should exist, to show beyond a reasonable doubt.
Instead of arguing that the natural world is not the way god intended it to be, the other approach is to claim the natural world really is good the way it isthat god made the world knowing that animals would eat each other, suffer in other ways, and even go extinct. The influence and legacy of deism in eighteenth century america. We can easily count the classics in the genre on one hand aliens, the thing, the fly, maybe even 2001 if you think hal9000 is a scary sonofabitch. But it was huxleys application of this principle to theistic and.
One does not use evolution to demonstrate abiogenesis, or newtonian gravity to demonstrate black holes. Deism pictures god as the great clockmaker who created the clock, wound it up, and let it go. The purpose is to show that science and faith are friendsnot enemies. It accepted religious knowledge that is inborn in every person and can be acquired by reason and rejected such knowledge that is acquired through revelation or. Recently ive been bemoaning the fact that scifi horror is one of the most woefully underexploited genres in hollywood. Deism is the belief that our universe was created by a god but that theres little. It is often defined as the belief that god exists, but here belief means something believed. As a former evangelical, who has studied almost every religion at least in a cursory manner, i am convinced that a personal, religiously affiliated, or intervening god does not exist and is a mere psychological projection. And, perhaps most important, why does the universe exist. Richard swinburne, author of the existence of god this is a remarkable book in many ways. We can confidently walk away from mike knowing his spherical cube of gold does not exist, in spite of the gold flakes he has produced. Something that is thought of by every human being must exist.
Dawkins has been professor of the public understanding of science at oxford university since 1996. As humans, we have an innate desire to understand the. There is a closedloop, singlepiece thread that makes up all of matter. Whats the problem with a deistic god as opposed to a theistic god. And may be yet some other things must be proved to prove some kind of god for real but thats no reason to negate the possibility. Deism became important during the age of enlightenment in 17th and 18th century western worldviews, also influencing some early american intellectuals and political leaders. God gave moses signs to prove to israel that god had sent him and to prove to pharaoh that the god of israel was the one true god ex 4. It posits a noninterventionist creator who permits the universe to run itself according to natural laws deism derives the existence and nature of god from reason and personal experience, rather than relying.
God exists, 100% beyond doubt, because this is impossible to do either way. Atheism and agnosticism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. God in america and usa weekend magazine are partnering to explore americans images of god. What would it take to convince an atheist that the. In the god delusion, dawkins contends that a supernatural creator almost certainly does not exist and that belief in a personal god qualifies as a delusion, which he defines as a persistent false belief held in the face of strong contradictory evidence. A deistic god would essentially be an absentee father god it would create a universe and then sit back and says i made you, but i dont want to get involved. Jeffersons religious beliefs thomas jeffersons monticello. Neither satan nor hell exists, only symbols of evil which can be overcome by mans own reasoning, all about philosophy confirmed. Philosophy of religion existence of god attributes of god god as creator ultimate destinies. In his 2006 book the god delusion, dawkins labels god and belief in god as delusions. Jefferson was deeply committed to core beliefs for example, the existence of a. Part i features arguments supporting my statement that the god of monotheism. I would highly recommend beth houstons latest book, natural god.
This book answers these questions and many more in a lucid and enjoyable style that will help the reader profoundly realize that there. But if you dont have any objection to those, and if you dont have an objection to davids ie, showing how one of his premises is false then you are. The theistic one that all the believers here talk about does intervene and therefore could be observed, yet hasnt been, so to my mind can and has been proven. William lane craig takes the reader on a tour of the arguments and does his best to debunk the notion that belief in god is intellectually indefensible. Deism, the religious attitude typical of the enlightenment, especially in france and england, holds that the only way the existence of god can be proven is to combine the application of reason with observation of the world. The core of this book contains the edited transcript of that debate. However, one can provide an educated answer to which is the most likely answer.
The best books on the existence of god ed feser on five books. Deism has no creed, articles of faith, or holy book. However, i had still remained somewhat agnostic toward the concept of a. The best arguments for gods existence dont challenge. Of course, every house is constructed by someone, but the one who constructed all things is god. The deists who presented purely rationalist proofs for the existence of god. Modern cosmology and astrophysics point to god as the source of the universe so strongly that, as astrophysicist hugh ross puts it, astronomers who do not draw theistic or deistic conclusions are becoming rare, and even the few dissenters hint that the tide is against them. Describe the difference between the deistic belief.
Wainwright, keith yandell and david yandell, critique the. The kcas conclusion is compatible with a deistic god, the islamic god, and the judeochristian god, so even though most of the worlds religions have been eliminated with that single argument, more narrowing still needs to be done. The stories of the bible were passed down to the authors of the book decades. The idea of god being a delusion is promoted by richard dawkins, the worlds chief apostle for atheism. Logical proof of a deistic god page 3 speculations. The words deism and theism are both derived from words meaning god. What is the difference between classical theism and theistic personalism. The characteristics that point to divine authorship are.
It accepted religious knowledge that is inborn in every person and can be. There are lots of mediocre to goodbutnotgreat scifi horror flicks pitch black, pandorum, mimic, event horizon. Deism derived from latin deus meaning god is a philosophical belief that posits that god exists as an uncaused first cause ultimately responsible for the creation of the universe, but does not interfere directly with the created world. In my case, i have chosen to concentrate my discussion on producing a probability value that directly answers the question of whether god exists. Best arguments for gods existence are actually terrible the new. Ive always eagerly read, listen, and disucussed this very serious matter of ultimate questions. Deism rejects claims that rely on supernatural occurrences or revealed knowledge. This argument does not claim to point to how god relates to man. Being, consciousness, bliss, and although i havent yet read it believe me, i will, and have ordered it, i posted a critique of damon linkers blurb for. It posits a noninterventionist creator who permits the universe to run itself according to natural laws. Equivalently, deism can also be defined as the view which posits gods existence as the cause of all things, and admits its perfection and. To all intents and purposes, hes irrelevant to us anyway.
This can be better understood with the marbles in a jar example. Second, here you admit that you can see no objection to these other god hypotheses. Consider, for example, the book of job, whose protagonist. The big argument is a response to the arguments used by atheists to try to defend their position.
Why god doesnt exist wgde presents a novel entity as a mediator for electromagnetism and gravity. The topic of the debate is does god exist, but so far you are arguing about which god exists. What good arguments exist to lend support and justification to. I cant be sure god does not exist he is regarded as the most famous atheist in the world but last night professor richard dawkins admitted he. Herbert, like his contemporary descartes, searched for the foundations of knowledge. We cannot prove the existence of god in a scientific way. Einstein the deist and flew the theist viewed from a christian. The possibility of a deistic god should be maintained open until demonstrated false i think.
Then he argued, less convincingly, against the existence of a deist god who created the universe and its. Deism in england and france in the 18th century wikipedia. Harry lee poe, a cousin of edgar allan poe, who promoted the concept in his book the gospel and its meaning. Logical proof of a deistic god discussion in alternative theories started by martillo, aug 6, 2017. What is the best argument against there being a god. From my point of view, a deistic god is indistinguishable from a nonexistent one, therefore doesnt exist. The god delusion is a 2006 book by english biologist richard dawkins, a professorial fellow at new college, oxford, and former holder of the charles simonyi chair for the public understanding of science at the university of oxford. Whenever you hear albert einstein or hawking talk about god they are talking about the physical laws of the universe, not the deity from the bible. Craig addresses this briefly, but i am not sure if you have gotten to that part yet or not. The proposal is that all atoms in existence are interconnected by a twined pair of threads. Well, first let me mention what the benefits of a deistic god are, so i dont come across all negative.
134 755 843 309 1622 1260 854 1549 583 940 1150 1631 112 851 472 666 599 1035 1230 1522 255 57 812 744 128 1464 271 968 113 1003 1007 1358 133 746 1316 943 1339 777 796 250 914 131 698 242 578 351 1464